Please wait, content is loading

SmartAPEX Journal · Wireless

Z-Wave vs Zigbee: choosing the wireless protocol for your smart home

Most people have heard of Zigbee. Fewer know Z-Wave, the radio inside SmartAPEX wireless keypads and thermostats. Here is how the wireless options differ, in plain words, and why we chose Z-Wave.

6 min read

Why not just use Wi-Fi?

Wi-Fi is built to move a lot of data: films, video calls, photos. A light switch sends only a few bytes, but they must arrive every time, within a moment, even while the router is busy. Every Wi-Fi device also connects straight to the router, so a house full of them puts all the load on one box.

Smart-home radios such as Z-Wave, Zigbee and Thread are made for the opposite job: small messages, very little power, and a mesh, in which devices pass each other’s messages along.

Wi-Fi: everything via the routerMesh: devices pass it onRouterOne box carries all the traffic.Many paths; each device helps.
Wi-Fi sends everything through one router. A mesh lets devices pass messages to each other, so there are many paths.

Smart home protocols: the four names you will hear

SmartAPEX wireless

Z-Wave

A mesh radio below 1 GHz made only for home control. One standard, overseen by the Z-Wave Alliance; a product must pass certification to carry the Z-Wave logo.

Best at: switches, thermostats, locks, sensors

Zigbee

A 2.4 GHz mesh built on the IEEE 802.15.4 radio and overseen by the Connectivity Standards Alliance. A very wide choice of devices.

Best at: bulbs, low-cost sensors

Wi-Fi

The home network itself. Fast and needs no hub, but each device talks to the router and uses more power.

Best at: cameras, TVs, speakers

Thread and Matter

Thread is a newer 2.4 GHz mesh that uses internet-style (IPv6) addresses. Matter, released in 2022, is a shared language that runs over Thread, Wi-Fi and Ethernet.

Best at: new devices that work across apps

Two radio lanes

The biggest difference is where each radio lives. Think of the radio spectrum as roads. 2.4 GHz is a busy highway shared by Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, Zigbee, Thread and even microwave ovens. Z-Wave drives on a quieter road below 1 GHz. The exact frequency depends on the country: for example 868.4 MHz in Europe and 908.4 MHz in North America.

2.4 GHzbusy< 1 GHzquietWi-FiZigbeeThreadBluetoothMicrowave ovenWi-FiZ-Wave
Zigbee, Thread, Wi-Fi and Bluetooth share the 2.4 GHz band. Z-Wave works below 1 GHz, where homes have far less radio traffic.

Lower frequencies also lose less strength through walls and over distance, at the same power. Real range still depends on the building, the antenna and the device, but in homes with concrete and block walls this helps.

concrete wall2.4 GHzweaker< 1 GHzstronger
Illustration: at the same power, the lower frequency keeps more of its strength after a concrete wall.

How a Z-Wave mesh network carries a message

In a mesh network, a message does not need a direct line to its target. Devices that are always powered, such as wall keypads and thermostats, pass it on. Classic Z-Wave allows up to four such hops and up to 232 devices in one network, which is plenty for a home. Zigbee also builds a mesh, and in theory it can address tens of thousands of devices, which matters more in very large buildings.

MajlisLiving roomMaster bedroomEntranceKitchenFamily roomZ-Wave hubHome CenterKeypadKeypadKeypad22°Thermostatconcrete wall
A command from the Home Center reaches a thermostat behind a concrete wall by hopping through two keypads on the way.

Z-Wave vs Zigbee: comparison table

Both are mature technologies used in millions of homes. This is how they compare on the points that matter in a house.

Z-Wave Zigbee
Radio band Below 1 GHz, set by country (868.4 MHz in Europe, 908.4 MHz in North America) 2.4 GHz, the same everywhere
Neighbours on the band Few in a typical home Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, Thread, microwave ovens
Through walls The lower frequency generally carries further Shorter reach per hop, so more devices are needed to relay
Network Mesh, up to 232 devices and 4 hops (classic Z-Wave) Mesh, tens of thousands of devices in theory
Speed 9.6 to 100 kbit/s, ample for control commands 250 kbit/s
Security S2: AES-128 encryption with a secure key exchange; required for certified devices since 2017 AES-128 encryption; install codes since Zigbee 3.0
Mixing brands Certification is required for every product, and newer generations work with older ones Zigbee 3.0 (ratified at the end of 2015) unified the device profiles; extra features can still differ between makers
Who makes the chips Very few makers: for most of its history a single chip maker in the United States, joined by a second supplier in 2024 Many chip makers around the world
Standard Z-Wave Alliance; radio layer published as ITU-T G.9959 Connectivity Standards Alliance; radio based on IEEE 802.15.4
Choice of devices Focused on home control Very large, especially bulbs and battery sensors
Z-WaveZigbeeFrom the startSince 2024Very few chip makersMany chip makers (illustration)
Z-Wave radios come from very few chip makers; Zigbee radios come from many.

Why SmartAPEX chose Z-Wave for smart switches and thermostats

A quieter radio lane

A wall switch has one job: work every time it is pressed. Below 1 GHz, our keypads and thermostats stay out of the crowded 2.4 GHz band, however many Wi-Fi devices the house has.

Reach through real walls

Many of the homes we work in are villas with concrete walls and several floors. The lower frequency, together with the mesh, carries messages around them.

The keypads build the network

SmartAPEX Z-Wave keypads and thermostats are always powered, so they relay messages for each other. Every room you add makes the network stronger.

One radio, tightly controlled

Z-Wave chips come from very few makers: for most of its history only one, in the United States, and since 2024 a second supplier. Zigbee chips come from many makers, which brings choice and also more room for differences between products. With Z-Wave the radio behaves the same way in every device.

One standard that stays compatible

Every Z-Wave product must be certified to carry the logo, and new generations work with older ones. S2 security, with AES-128 encryption, protects the house from the moment a device joins.

Built for the house you already have

No new cables. The keypads come with With-Neutral and Non-Neutral back-units for existing wall boxes, use a Z-Wave 800 Series chip, and take firmware updates over the air without removing the faceplate.

One look, wired or wireless

Our Z-Wave keypads use the same Crystal glass and Classic metal faceplates as our wired CAN range, so a house can mix both and every room still matches.

At the centre sits the SmartAPEX Home Center wall panel, which is itself a Z-Wave hub: it adds and removes devices, uses S2 security and keeps its own backup of the Z-Wave network.

Wired or wireless smart home?

Radio is ideal once the walls are finished. When a house is being built or fully renovated, a wired bus is the stronger base, because it needs no radio at all. Our rule of thumb: wired CAN while the walls are open, Z-Wave once the plaster is on. Both can live in the same house. Read how the wired side works in CAN bus vs KNX: how a wired smart home works.

Frequently asked questions

Is Z-Wave better than Zigbee?

Neither is better everywhere. Z-Wave works below 1 GHz, away from Wi-Fi, and every product must be certified, which suits wall switches and thermostats. Zigbee offers a wider choice of low-cost devices at 2.4 GHz. SmartAPEX uses Z-Wave for its wireless keypads and thermostats.

Does Z-Wave interfere with Wi-Fi?

No. Z-Wave uses a band below 1 GHz (868.4 MHz in Europe, 908.4 MHz in North America), while Wi-Fi uses 2.4 GHz and higher bands.

How many devices can a Z-Wave network have?

Up to 232 devices in a classic Z-Wave mesh, with a message relayed over up to four hops. That is plenty for a home.

Do I need a hub for Z-Wave?

Yes. A Z-Wave network has one controller. In a SmartAPEX home it is the Home Center wall panel, which is a Z-Wave hub with S2 security; SmartAPEX Z-Wave keypads also work with other compatible Z-Wave controllers.

Can I add a smart home to a house that is already finished?

Yes. Z-Wave needs no new cables. SmartAPEX Z-Wave keypads fit existing wall boxes, with With-Neutral and Non-Neutral back-units.

Planning a smart home? The SmartAPEX Home Planner suggests keypads, thermostats and modules room by room, and sends your plan to us.

Open the Home Planner

Standards referred to: Z-Wave (ITU-T G.9959, Z-Wave Alliance), Zigbee and Matter (Connectivity Standards Alliance, IEEE 802.15.4), Thread (Thread Group). Figures are those published for each standard; range in a real home depends on the building.