SmartAPEX Journal · Wired
CAN bus vs KNX: how a wired smart home works
KNX is the best-known wired standard for smart buildings. CAN bus is better known in cars and machines, and it is the backbone of the SmartAPEX wired range. Here is what a bus is, how the wired options compare, and why we chose CAN.
Why choose a wired smart home?
Wireless is convenient, but a cable has no radio interference and no range limit, and nothing on it needs batteries. When the walls are open, during building or a full renovation, laying a bus cable is a small step that serves the house for decades.
What is a bus in home automation?
In a traditional house, every switch is wired straight to its light. With a bus, one data cable visits every device in turn, like a bus route that stops at every house on the street. Any device can put a message on the line, and the device it is meant for acts on it. A keypad no longer needs a cable to each light it controls; it only needs to be on the bus.
Wired smart home protocols: CAN bus, KNX, RS-485 and DALI
CAN bus
A two-wire bus created for vehicles in 1986 and standardised as ISO 11898. Today it runs in cars, trucks, machines, lifts and medical equipment. Each manufacturer defines its own messages on top of it.
Keypads, thermostats, DIN-rail modules
KNX
An open standard for home and building automation (ISO/IEC 14543-3, EN 50090), with roots in 1990. More than 500 manufacturers make KNX devices.
Multi-brand building automation
RS-485 and Modbus
A simple two-wire line on which one master asks each device in turn. Common on air-conditioning gateways, energy meters and curtain motors.
Climate, meters, curtains
DALI
A bus made for lighting control (IEC 62386): up to 64 addresses on one line, with groups and scenes. DALI-2 adds standard push-buttons and sensors.
Dimmable and colour lighting
Smart home wiring: two ways to lay the cable
KNX allows a free layout: the cable may branch like a tree or a star, as long as it never closes into a loop. A bus power supply feeds each line at about 30 V DC. One line segment takes up to 64 devices and 1,000 m of cable, and repeaters extend a line to 256 devices.
CAN uses a single line from device to device, closed by a 120 Ω resistor at each end. The standard allows up to 1 Mbit/s on short cables; the longer the cable, the lower the speed that is chosen. SmartAPEX runs its CAN bus at 20 kbit/s, a deliberately low speed that suits long cable runs through a house, and still about twice the speed of KNX on twisted pair.
CAN bus vs KNX: comparison table
| CAN bus | KNX (twisted pair) | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A communication bus (ISO 11898). Each maker defines its own messages on it | A complete automation standard with shared device rules (ISO/IEC 14543-3) |
| Cable | One twisted pair: CAN-H and CAN-L | A twisted-pair bus cable that also carries bus power |
| Layout | One line, a 120 Ω resistor at each end | Line, tree or star; no closed loops |
| Speed | SmartAPEX runs it at 20 kbit/s for long cable runs; the standard allows up to 1 Mbit/s on short ones | 9,600 bit/s |
| Who can talk | Any device. A built-in priority decides who goes first, without losing a message | Any device; no central controller needed |
| When something goes wrong | Every message is checked, a damaged one is sent again, and a faulty device takes itself off the bus | Messages are checked and acknowledged, and repeated if needed |
| Mixing brands | The bus is open, but the messages belong to each maker: one family works together, and other systems join through gateways | Devices from many manufacturers work on the same bus |
| Setting up | The maker’s own tools | ETS engineering software, sold under licence by the KNX Association |
| Best known in | Vehicles, machines, lifts | Homes and commercial buildings |
Why SmartAPEX chose CAN bus for its wired smart home system
Proven where failure is not an option
CAN was designed for vehicles, where a lost message is not acceptable, and moved on to machines, lifts and medical equipment. It carries the signal as the difference between its two wires, which makes it very resistant to noise from motors and power cables.
Devices talk to each other directly
Any SmartAPEX CAN device can be bound to another: a keypad to a relay channel, a sensor input to a group of lights. Everyday control does not depend on a central controller, and the links are drawn in a browser on the Bindings map.
Errors are handled by the bus
Checking every message, resending damaged ones and switching off a faulty device are built into CAN itself, not added later in software.
Updates over the same cable
From the Mini IP gateway’s web page, keypads, thermostats and inputs on the bus are found, set up and updated, several of them together, without taking a single faceplate off the wall.
One family, designed together
Keypads, thermostats, relay modules, the DALI gateway, the 16-channel digital input and the Mini IP gateway are made to work together, with the same Crystal and Classic faceplates in every room.
Open to the rest of the house
The Mini IP gateway links the CAN network to Ethernet, to Modbus devices such as air-conditioning gateways and energy meters, and to RS-485 curtain motors. The DALI gateway brings DALI lighting into the same system.
Cost of ownership: the years after installation
When you compare wired systems, look beyond the list of devices and ask who can change things later, and with what. A KNX system is programmed with the ETS software: the professional licence sits on a USB licence key or in the cloud (which then needs a permanent internet connection), the computer reaches the bus through a KNX interface, and the work is done by a trained integrator who keeps the ETS project file. A SmartAPEX CAN system is set up from the web pages built into its own modules, in a browser, with no software licence and no project file. Whichever you choose, ask for the wiring drawings at hand-over.
Wired or wireless?
Our rule of thumb: wired CAN while the walls are open, Z-Wave once the plaster is on. The two can live in the same house with the same faceplates. Read about the wireless side in Z-Wave vs Zigbee: choosing the wireless protocol for your smart home.
Frequently asked questions
What is CAN bus in home automation?
CAN bus is a two-wire data bus from the vehicle industry, standardised as ISO 11898. In a SmartAPEX home, keypads, thermostats and DIN-rail modules talk to each other over one CAN twisted pair.
Is CAN bus an alternative to KNX?
For a SmartAPEX system, yes: it links keypads, thermostats and outputs over one cable, and the links are made in a browser. KNX remains the natural choice when a project must mix many brands on one bus.
What cable does a CAN bus need?
One twisted pair, CAN-H and CAN-L, run as a line from device to device with a 120 Ω resistor at each end. Follow the installer manual for the cable type and length.
Does a wired smart home need a central controller?
Not for everyday control. SmartAPEX CAN devices are bound directly to each other, so a keypad switches its relay channel without a central controller in between.
Can wired and wireless be mixed in one house?
Yes. Wired CAN suits rooms built while the walls are open, Z-Wave suits finished rooms, and both use the same Crystal and Classic faceplates.
Building or renovating? The SmartAPEX Home Planner suggests keypads, thermostats and modules room by room, and sends your plan to us.
Standards referred to: CAN (ISO 11898), KNX (ISO/IEC 14543-3, EN 50090), RS-485 (TIA/EIA-485), Modbus, DALI (IEC 62386). Figures are those published for each standard.